The one thing wrong with Oneonta Falls was that there were more people than I expected. It's such an amazing little gorge to hike up, but the crowds detracted from it somewhat.
Hamilton Mountain is another great hike, though also has the potential for a few more people on the trail. My parents and I hiked that trail for Mother's Day a few years ago. It was a great hike, but it was still pretty cold. It even snowed (well, slushed) and the wind was pretty strong. Dad and I haven't quite let Mom forget that one.