Do both my bareroot Neofinetias look okay?

[Grawski]

Good afternoon Orchid Board members. I'm Gary Shangraw, and just joined the Board. I'm 72 years old, and happily married. I live in the United States, in the State of Vermont. On a map of the US, it's the far right upper corner. I am an avid plant grower, almost all Epiphytes. Recently, my path has led me to attempt growing Orchids. I have spent quite a bit of time researching the care guides for these beautiful plants. I have used this site in the past, but not as a member.

Today, I have 3 photos. The first photo is a Neofinetia, with a new root tip. This plant seems to be fine.

The 2nd and 3rd photos are different Neofinetia. I have concerns regarding the blacken area at the plant base. I'm hoping for some good news regarding it's condition.

My future plan for these 2 plants are to attempt semi-hydro. But for now, the health of the 2nd plant is my focus.

Thank you all for any comments you provide.