![]() |
How do _you_ pronounce Stanhopea?
I have always pronounced it:
stan-hope-e-a pronouncing both of the final two characters, long e, short a (ah). I was reading somewhere yesterday, I think an AOS web page where it was said, that while the pronunciation that I use is common, the correct pronunciation is: stan-hope-ah the e is not pronounced. The AOS pronunciation makes sense. Do others agree and how do _you_ pronounce Stanhopea? |
Like you, I have always used Stan-HOPE-ee-uh, but as it is named after someone whose surname was "Stanhope", the AOS recommendation should be proper.
Then there's one of my favorites: neofinetia. I have heared Nee-oh-fin-EESH-ah and Nee-oh-fin-eh-TEE-ah, but the French botanist's name is pronounced Fee-Nay, so I suppose it ought to be Nee-oh-fee-NAY-ee-ah |
David,
Your pronunciation of Stanhopea is correct as far as I know. In fact, I've never heard it pronounced the way the AOS states it should be. Ray, I have also heard both versions of Neofinetia, but was corrected one time by Les Kawamoto's son (I wish I could remember his name) of Kawamoto Orchids in Hawaii. Ever since then I have pronounced it Nee-oh-fin-EESH-ah instead of Nee-oh-fin-eh-TEE-ah, as I had been saying. |
Steve,
Sorry, but I have to disagree. Just because "experts" say it one way, that doesn't mean it's correct. When an honorific name is applied to a genus or species, the name should be pronounced just as the person that it honors does (or did). For example, there are a number of genera named after the American botanist, Oakes Ames. His last name is prounced just like "aims". One of those genera is "amesia", which is properly pronounced Aims-ee-ah, even though it could be improperly done as Ah-Mee-see-ah. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Finet is not exactly pronounced Fee NAY, americans love to make the 'et' sound much stronger than it actually is. 'et' is actually pronounced like the first e in the words 'estate' or 'esteem'.
And in France I have mostly heard it prononced with the 't' being audible, so Nee-oh-fin-eh-TEE-ah. In Finet's name the t is silent, but usually with words like that once you add a vowel after it the t is pronounced. This is also getting into the issues of botanical names being pronounced a bit differently in different language. I frequently say orchid names the 'frenchified' way, because that's how I learned plant names in my botany classes in France... |
Quote:
|
It's not necessarily the 'right' way to pronounce it in English though. Each language tends to adapt the the pronunciation a bit. There is also more variation in pronunciation of plants named after people. For instance, for Paph rothschildianum I believe that in English the 'child' part is pronounced with a long 'i' sound. In French it's with more of an 'e' sound, like in the word 'me'.
But I don't think pronunciation is the most important. As long as we use the right names and can make ourselves understood, I think it's all that really matters. Even among scientists we don't pronounce things the same. Many of us in my research group work with a butterfly genus called Pieris (white cabbage butterflies). Some of us say Pee-riss, others say Pee-er-iss while a few people say Pie-russ. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:11 AM. |
3.8.9
Search Engine Optimisation provided by
DragonByte SEO v2.0.37 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.