![]() |
Physan 20
I didn't know physan could be so harmful. I mixed maybe half a teaspoon with some water in a small glass and applied some to a root tip that had some mold on it, and it certainly did take care of the mold... as well as dissolve some of the root tip away!
I think my s/h case has gone from bad to worse. that root was looking pretty good, it was maybe a half inch long and I was thinking it would be adapt and grow well into the S/H and would become a main root, but now I have my doubts. The only roots I have remaining are two semi brown ones that are older and didn't completely die during the transition, and some nubbins... some of which have stopped growing. Though b/c I have a new leaf coming, I figure it's not all THAT bad?? |
I limit my use of Physan to 1 teaspoon per gallon. Your mixture is probably 20x that concentrated, and it IS, after all, a mixture of quaternary ammonium salts.
|
Physan 20
I don't do hydroponics, but, I know Physan is very concentrated. A drop or two in that amount of water would have been plenty.
I have used it in the past mostly to spray my amaryllis (hippeastrum) when they are just sprouting in the early spring. They get a rust that, if not contained, keep the plants from flowering. I only put maybe a teaspoon in the spray bottle for this application. You can always use a slightly stronger concentration if you see the weaker does not quite do the job. And the old saying, "if all else fails, read the instructions". I just bought a new bottle and there are quite extensive instructions included. Beverly A. |
Yeah, I mix 1/4 tsp with 32 oz water in a spray bottle.
|
Physan is the same as the algaecide sold in pool supply houses. (It is much cheaper there as well)
For a pool the rate is 20 ounces to 10,000 gallons so keep this in mind when using it on plants. Once you damage the growing tip of a root it will never grow again (but the root will still support the plant). The plant will however put out new roots. be patient. |
Jerry, that is a most interesting comment about pool algicides. Here in England, our authorities conspired last year with the EU to ban Physan sales - worse than that, vendors were instructed to destroy any remaining stocks (but I have no idea how they went about that safely).
We are all still looking for a viable alternative . I have a swimming pool, but would not like to use any pool algicide on my orchids without further input. Do you have, or can you direct me to, any information/experience at all which would help me (chemical constituents I should look for etc)? We really do need to find some sort of viable substitute for Physan which was a brilliant product so the pool chemicals sounds great to me. Richard |
Pool algaecides are not the identical chemicals, but they are quite close, and are effective, but then again, so is household laundry (chlorine) bleach.
|
Quote:
|
Ray
HTH brand and several others are the exact chemicals as physan. You can compare the labels. HTH is 50% stronger than physan but that just makes it even cheaper. I should have been clearer that not all algaecide are the same, but there are several that match Physan exactly. |
Good to know, Jerry.
Thanks. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:00 PM. |
3.8.9
Search Engine Optimisation provided by
DragonByte SEO v2.0.37 (Lite) -
vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2025 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.