We have ongoing problems with biosduval scale here. I usually control it with isopropyl alcohol. It’s made me wonder - how does the alcohol work. Does it poison, smother or something else?
I would kind of wonder whether the orchid leaf also has a waxy or another membrane that can be "killed" by certain harsh chemicals. Hydrogen peroxide is well known for being a cellular killer, cytotoxic, and yet people throw it around on everything with wild abandon.