Oh NO! yours was gorgeous! Glad you got a replacement! :)
I got one too after seeing yours!

And for my latest bit of madness, since I couldn't find variablis in Canada I decided to find all the Maxilaria I could in all 3 (minus Tenufolia of course since it's been done...) (All Can, US, EU, flowering size unless otherwise stated)

Maxillaria Cucullata
Paramount 28,
Andy’s 18/24 (both blooming), Carolina 20,
Burnham (listed as Camaridium cucullatum?) flowering size £15
IOSPE PHOTOS

Maxillaria Schunkeana
Paramount 30,
Andy’s 35,
Burnham (Brasiliorchis Schunkiana) Near flowering £10, Großräschener 17,
IOSPE PHOTOS

Maxillaria Marginata
Hawaiian Botanicals 25 (low yes),
Andy’s 25/28,
Großräschener FS 16
IOSPE PHOTOS (has it cool to cold, but Andy’s says tolerant?)

Maxillaria picta
Hawaiian Botanicals 17 (sold out, check?),
Andy’s $25.
Burnham young plants £10, Großräschener 18,
IOSPE PHOTOS

I would definitely vote for the Maxillaria schunkeana! It can be grown at intermediate temps as well.

+1

I like this one too!

With the prices shown, its much too high.

It's very beautiful. Personally I prefer to have as many scented plants as possible. This one is not scented and therefore would not be at the top of my list..

Oops! I only looked at the EU price... It's been a long day and I'm tired. :blushing:

I've updated the list. The Encyclia is taken off the 'good' list, and I've only added Max. cucullata. The other Max species went to the maybe list, if cheaper growers can be found.

Depending on how many candidates we get, I may remove the ones that are a bit expensive in Canada (some are at $28!)

Also, a question. What do you all think about Lycaste aromatica? Anyone object to a plant above the size limit, with really long leaves? Being deciduous it doesn't take up so much space in the winter.

I've decided to move Brassavola nodosa into the possible candidate list, since it does take a long time for it to become large.

Lycaste aromatica would get a go from me. It doesnt seem that large aside from its leaves but its fragrant which gives it the go ahead. Also, doesnt seem that large in the sizes we will be buying it in either.

This is my first project so, I was wondering when do we start voting?