Quote:
Originally Posted by keithrs
I do agree with blazingaugust. There needs to be a standard that a mod puts in place. Maybe start a new thread for ideas to set a standard? I want it to be far for all. If a sept. project is to late of those in colder climates then x-na it.
|
I think setting rules for ALL projects would be too restrictive.
For example Cody (blazingaugust) ran a Canadian based one recently. If we had had rules in place for all Projects they would have stated the plant must be available for a given price in the USA and Europe, stopping him from running one that was based around availability in Canada instead.
Sometimes it's nice to vary and do something different to other times. We usually have a certain size and temperature zone, but maybe for a change it would be nice to have a project in a different range.
I think it's generally better for the person running the project to set the critirea. All the ones I've seen over the last few years have stated the criteria at the beginning. If someone has picked some 'way-out' criteria then people won't join the project, it won't go ahead and something else will be thought of instead. Criteria can be discussed and if there is general agreement tweaked and changed (in my last one I set the plant size too high for most people so I reduced it) but as Dave has said ultimately it's up to the person running it to decide and to find criteria that attracts enough people to take part.
Allowing those running the projects to have flexibility in the criteria allows a more varied range of projects to keep the interest and fun going.
We always try and keep things relaxed here on Orchid Board and I feel (this is my personal feeling) that making the criteria of projects too restrictive would make them too rigid for the relaxed atmosphere of our board.
Just my