I have one that almost died Silken, I've been tempted by getting a new one, but sort of want to prove I can save this one first. It's been about 3 years and it got down to one rootless p-bulb (the rest of the growth rotted off, the the roots followed later). I was about to throw it out not long after and noticed a tiny growth. It developed then rotted off, but there was a new growth behind it... which developed a tiny p-bulb then rotted off. That cycle repeated 3 times but each time left behind new roots. Anyway, the one early this year didn't rot and while it's bulb is quite small it's bigger than previous ones and it's still there with another new growth beside it. I used seaweed extract with it over the summer and it as these fat fat roots coming out of the new growth. We shall see... I hope it might be happy at last