Quote:
Originally Posted by littlefrog
Don't change your tag... Rumor is afoot that the cattleya alliance will be shuffled yet again.
Personally I ignore any tag that uses Guaranthe in the name. Actually of all the changes that one makes the most sense, but I'm not changing my tags. All of my encyclias are still labeled encyclia, too.
|
Not to confuse the issue or to throw fuel on the fire,but, in this case the Lc label is correct. Once a plant is awarded it is correct and proper to retain the original genus name even if they have been reclassified.
The taxonomists are scientists and not botanists and couldn't give a rats behind about the confusion and inconvenience all of their reclassifications cause. The real confusion comes when different genera are condensed into one and there are hybrids of the same name from multiple genera, which is against the rules of RHS orchid nomenclature.
I for one like the old names, especially in the hybrids of the Cattleya alliance plants, when one says Cattleya, Laelia or Sophronitis one can picture the basic shape of the flower being talked about. When they are combined into one genus it's any ones guess what the flower may look like without knowing the whole genealogy.