I think lighting is a very touchy topic for all of us... I think there is a lot of information out there and even more conflicting views.
I may have missed a few posts after editing, but it seems there is a concensus about attempting to hit the chrlorophyll spectra and not all lights being forthcoming enough to really gauge their value. we all have variations on the same theme, and it's important to remember we're all shooting for the same goal... Cheers!
There is a great article here:
Aqua Botanic-light bulb comparison
Covers PAR rating, which I think would be useful in comparing how valuable a lighting source is for chrlorophyll absorption.
I saw a recent video by National Semiconductor and Philips Lumileds (the high power LED people) about LEDs and plant growth, and they were saying basically that the spectrum of the 3 Red/Green/Blue LED lights out there on the market TOTALLY miss the chrlorophyll absorption region. If anyone is interested. I can post the link, it's a video about 150megs, but well worth it if you are interested in LEDs.