Your greenhouse would have about 500 square feet of surface area exposed to the outside cold. If you were to keep the inside at 70 f on a zero degree night it would take about 40000 btu per hour to maintain the temperature. Natural gas has roughly 1000 btu per cubic foot plus there is an efficiency of the furnace to consider, maybe 80%. So it would require about 40000/.8= 50000 btu per hour input to the heater, or about 50 cubic feet of natural gas. Natural gas is sold by 100 cuft. In Ohio current gas costs are about $1.37/ 100 cuft so it would cost about $.70 an hour during the night to keep the temp at 70 f.
This is based on using a single layer of 1/8" glass as the glazing. If you used something like double or triple wall polycarbonate glazing the heating cost really goes down. Using something like 16mm 5 wall polycarbonate would reduce the gas consumption to about 15000 btu per hour. A big savings over 50000 btu/hr.
Here's a link to a calculator to figure how much heat is required for different glazing materials. This will give you how many btu's you need per hour. If you really want some scary numbers try +70 f on a -20 f night.
Try some different glazing materials and inside temps to see what it would cost. That 5 wall polycarbonate starts to look pretty cheap after a while.
Ron
ACF Greenhouse Heaters & Heater Size + Cost to Heat Calculators