Like you, I'd choose the more well rounded one. Ray has done some research that indicates the the Nitrogen is the key fertilizer element (it's someone on the OB). Most of the OB members have indicated that their experience is that bloom boosting fert doesn't really do much, and that has been my experience as well.
Ray's studies indicate that it is better to fert more often (like every watering). I water about 6 items a month with fert and once without, but I ran the calculation is if always using fert. So I am using slightly less that the calculator would suggest for my habits, but I figure that is safer. (I use an MSU fert - just switched)
I also just started to use SuperThrive and I must say that I saw almost immediate response in root growth. I add about 2 drops/gallon at every watering.
So in the end, you will need to do some experiments to see how your orchids respond to your fertilizing regimen in your conditions. There are no one-size-fits-all care formulas for orchids!