Quote:
Originally Posted by spes1959@gmail.com
Maybe I didn't get into it well I didn't want to replace fertilizers with microalgae extracts but I just wanted to know if anyone had experience in this field as I think many of you have with Kelpak.
|
There's some research that specifically uses Kelpak. An interesting one compares Kelpak which contains polyamines with direct inoculation of polyamines and the results showed that the Kelpak-treated plants grew better whereas the polyamine ones weren't significantly better than the control.
I'm not sure what the story of this product is, or how anyone thought that the specific type of algae they use would have effects not seen in any other kelp extracts. What we know is that it's a commercial product and both its content and extraction process are potentially trade secrets so don't expect any other Kelp extract to just work in the same way. The company owning Kelpak also seems to have made sure their product is well studied so it's also hard to find comparable evidence since not all conditions would be equal for all kelp products.
The presence of cytokinins plays a role, which is the reason why people experiment with coconut water which is naturally rich in cytokinins. Yet, Kelpak has a higher content of auxins than cytokinins. Go figure.
I use it, I use a lot of it, as well as Quantum. I haven't found any other product that compares. Before I started to order products from Ray I ran different experiments with Kelp extracts and probiotics from Amazon. The random kelp extracts did absolutely nothing. I ran an experiment treating three plants with a probiotic from Bloom City, while the rest of my collection was treated with Quantum. The Bloom City plants were significantly slower growers.